A detail I have noticed in news stories about the current Syrian unrest is that demonstrations tend to happen on Fridays-because that is when people are already assembled in their mosques. I think that illustrates one desirable effect of religions, including Islam, even from the standpoint of someone like me who doesn't agree with any of them.
A religion is an ideology, and as such is a competitor with other ideologies such as nationalism. The Syrian government feels free to do a lot of things. But it isn't free to simply tear down all the mosques and announce that assemblies on Friday are illegal and will be punished.
In the Syrian case the situation is complicated by the fact that the government is dominated by an arguably heretical Muslim sect, which limits its ability to co-opt the major Islamic groups within the country-contrast that to the situation in Iran, where the government is controlled by the majority Twelver Shia sect. During the Nazi period, the Christian churches did not, so far as I can judge, do an awful lot to constrain what the governments were doing, although of course some individual Christians did. But still competition, even limited competition, is valuable. Even in Iran, I suspect the government is to some degree constrained by the fact that prominent Shia scholars have reputations and from them authority that doesn't derive directly from any official position.
Thursday, 31 January 2013
Related Posts:
Five Aspects Of An Effective Prayer LifeThis is an abbreviated checking account of the feeling I gave at a another ladies blind date.In the flash state Jesus is teaching his disciples a secret lesson on the power of prayer. He knew that he was about to be crucified… Read More
The Worlds Oldest Kurd A Beloved 114 Year Old Rabbi In The Heart Of The Holy City "THE WORLD'S OLDEST KURD: A BELOVED 114 YEAR OLD RABBI IN THE HEART OF THE HOLY CITY"."By Lazar Berman.""IN A HUMBLE APARTMENT IN YERUSHALAYIM'S BAKA NEIGHBORHOOD, ABOUT A MILE SOUTH OF THE WALLS OF THE OLD CITY, THE WORLD'S… Read More
Evening Roundup Feria Of Advent Feria Iii Infra Hebdomadam Ii Adventus Missa Populus Sion December 9Th 2014 * "AGGIE CATHOLICS (MARCEL)" 35 PROMISES OF GOD * "CATHOLICHERALD.CO.UK (ED WEST)" PRINCE CHARLES: ISIS ARE SENDING THE WORLD BACK TO THE DARK AGES * "CATHOLIC STAND (HOWARD DUNCAN) " WE LIKE MESSAGES, DON'T WE? * "CATHOLI… Read More
What Is It To Live Without Sin What Is Active Evil*I feel that the modern understanding of what it is to live without sin is mistaken.This mistake means that the very worst sinners feel clean and pure, and react incredulously to any notion that they are faithful and diligent… Read More
Multiculturalism Has No Place In Israel "Multiculturalism has no place in Israel.Israel was created as a Jewish state for the Jews" HERALD SUN Australia's biggest-selling daily newspaper September 27, 2000 Multiculturalism not for Israel - LeiblerBy John… Read More